Winning the Hearts and Minds of Afghan Farmers
Sunday, March 21st, 2010KABUL, Afghanistan — The effort to win over Afghans on former Taliban turf in Marja has put American and NATO commanders in the unusual position of arguing against opium eradication, pitting them against some Afghan officials who are pushing to destroy the harvest.
From Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal on down, the military’s position is clear: “U.S. forces no longer eradicate,” as one NATO official put it. Opium is the main livelihood of 60 to 70 percent of the farmers in Marja.
If this policy makes sense in Marja (which it does), why not in the entire country? Destroying farmers’ livelihood can only drive them away from U.S. allegiance and into the arms of the Taliban.
An even better policy, of course, is to legalize opium farming. This brings the activity entirely above ground.
And legalizing opium is not the same as legalizing heroin. Opium production or poppy cultivation is already legal in numerous countries, including Australia, Austria, China, the Czech Republic, Estonia, France, Germany, Hungary, Japan, India, the Netherlands, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, South Korea, Spain, Macedonia, Turkey, and the United Kingdom. The opium or poppy straw from this production yields the morphine, codeine, and other alkaloids used in medical provision.
The main effects of legalizing opium production in Afghanistan, therefore, are to help Afghani farmers and eliminate a profit source for the Taliban. Sounds like a plan to me.
